Know your neighbors, know your town, empower the community.

Do I Need Surgery For My Rotator Cuff Tear?

July 4, 2024
Time to read:
A man in a white t - shirt holding his neck

One of the most commonly injured areas of the body is the shoulder.  It is a dynamic joint, allowing us the greatest mobility of any articulating joint.  But with great mobility, comes great potential for injury.

If you’re like most people, you have likely injured your shoulder a handful of times before.  Tweaked it.  Strained it.  Slept on it the wrong way.  Maybe it got better, or maybe, just maybe, its still bothering you to this day.

When patients seek out physical therapy services for their injured shoulder, the most frequently impacted area is the rotator cuff.  The rotator cuff is made up of four separate muscles (no, it is not one big muscle!):  Supraspinatus, Infraspinatus, Teres Minor, and Subscapularis.  

Each of the four rotator cuff muscles has its own motion to create.  However, the common responsibility is to support the humerus (long bone of the upper arm) while it articulates/moves on the glenoid fossa, creating stability.  This joint looks much like if you put a golf ball on a tee and tipped it sideways.  Without the rotator cuff, the joint would have little support to hold it in position or to create the tremendous motion we have become accustomed to.

While a teenager who injures their rotator cuff may end up dealing with a muscle strain or tendinitis, there is great concern among many adults who injure their shoulder that they may have torn their rotator cuff.  

Typically, a rotator cuff tear is accompanied by substantial pain, weakness and limited movement   Most rotator cuff tears occur later in life as we age as a normal part of wear and tear on the shoulder.  However, traumatic tears from falls or accidents, as well as repetitive overuse injuries can occur commonly.

  Most rotator cuff tears do not require surgery and are much better treated conservatively with physical therapy.  Strengthening the musculature around the torn tendon can reduce strain on the injured area and decrease pain while improving stability and mobility.  Seeing your physical therapist in the early onset of injury can help expediate your healing and reduce medical expenses.

  Surgery is looked at as a last resort to improve a rotator cuff tear.  Typically, if conservative measures such as Physical Therapy, cortisone injections, and other medications have not allowed for substantial improvement to restore function and decrease pain then surgery will be a likely next step.  Imaging such as MRI will be performed to assess the tear and the Orthopedic Surgeon will create the best approach to correct the tear.

After surgery, most patients are sent home post-op with a sling they will wear for several weeks to allow the repaired tendon to fully heal.  However, most patients begin PT shortly after surgery to restore range of motion and begin strengthening muscles that will support the repaired area.  A protocol will be followed to maximize your results and protect the repair.  Most patients regain full range of motion within 2-4 months after surgery.  Strength and stability of the shoulder will progress over this time as well.  Full return to sports and high level activities typically occurs by 6-9 months following surgery.

 If surgery is the preferred option, one should seriously consider “PreHab” short for “Preoperative Rehabilitation”. This allows a patient to maximize their range of motion and strength while reducing as much pain as possible before surgery.  By going into a rotator cuff repair, as well as any other orthopedic or neurological procedure, with the best possible mobility, strength, and pain control, you will enhance your post operative results dramatically.  Typically, PREHAB not only reduces post operative pain, but also improves the rate at which you achieve full range of motion and strength.

For patients, friends, and family, PREHAB is a no-brainer before surgery.The question of whether or not to have surgery is a complex one and should not be taken lightly.  There are pro and cons as well as risks and benefits to both conservative and surgical treatment of a rotator cuff tear.  The important thing is to consult with your team of experts to help you explore all your options and make the right choice for yourself.

If you need help determining what choice is best for you, our team is here to help.  You can schedule an evaluation by reaching us at (203) 389-4593 or visit

Kyle Branday MSPT,C-PS

Kyle is a licensed Physical Therapist and is the supervisor of the Woodbridge office. He is a graduate of Quinnipiac University where he earned his Master’s degree in Physical Therapy. In addition, Kyle is Level 2 Certified by the Institute of Advanced Musculoskeletal Treatment for Dry Needling. He enjoys treating patients with a wide range of orthopedic and neurological conditions.

Kyle has extensive training in the diagnosis and treatment of acute and chronic orthopedic and sports injuries, neurological rehabilitation, manual therapy, sports specific training, Selective Functional Movement Assessment (SFMA) and works with patients ranging from pediatrics to geriatrics.

Recently, he has completed course work to earn designation as a Champion Performance Specialist (C-PS) to enhance his work with elite athletes and weekend warriors alike. Kyle is an avid sports fan and works with our patients in our Sports Performance Programs.

This is an opinion not necessarily endorsed by the Woodbridge Town News.

Related articles